Marketing

Customer acquisition cost for online stores: blended, paid and break-even

What one new customer costs: the CAC formula three ways, worked through on one store's month, and held against what a first order leaves after its costs.

The short answer

Customer acquisition cost, CAC, is marketing spend divided by the new customers won in the same period. Blended CAC divides all spend by every new customer; paid CAC divides ad spend by the customers who came through a paid click. Hold either against break-even CAC: what a first order leaves after products, shipping and payment fees.

Customer acquisition cost, CAC, is what it costs to win one new customer: the marketing spend of a period divided by the new customers won in it. For an online store the formula has three versions worth knowing, blended, fully loaded and paid, and one number to hold each of them against: the most a first order can cost before it loses money. This guide works all four through on one store's month, with every figure computed, and says which one to steer on.

In short

  • Blended CAC is all marketing spend divided by all new customers. It cannot count a customer twice.
  • Fully loaded CAC adds what it costs to run the marketing: agency fees, creative, influencer budgets.
  • Paid CAC is ad spend divided by the new customers who arrived through a paid click. It is stricter, and it needs attribution.
  • Hold each against what a first order leaves after products, shipping and payment fees. Below that, a first order pays for its own customer.

The formula

CAC is marketing spend divided by new customers, both from the same period. New means a customer whose first ever order falls in the period: a repeat buyer won last year is not won again by this month's ads, and counting them makes acquisition look cheaper than it is. Spend means what the platforms billed, read from their billing pages rather than from the conversions their dashboards report, plus whatever else the store paid to be found.

On one store's month: €15.000 of advertising, 706 orders, 62% of them from first-time customers. That is 438 new customers and a blended CAC of €34,25. The short definition, with the same month, is in the glossary entry on customer acquisition cost in ecommerce.

Blended, fully loaded, paid: three answers from one month

Fully loaded CAC adds the cost of running the marketing to the media. Say the store pays an agency €2.000 a month to run its campaigns: spread over the same 438 customers, CAC rises to €38,81. Whether salaries belong in it is a choice; including them gives the cost of the whole function, leaving them out keeps CAC a cost that moves with the budget. Say which, and keep to it.

Paid CAC divides the ad spend by only the new customers whose first order came through a paid click, 290 of them by the store's own tracking tags, and comes to €51,72. The other 148 found the store through search, a friend or an old newsletter, and blended CAC spreads the spend over them too.

CACFormulaThis monthFirst order leaves
Blendedad spend ÷ all new customers€34,25+€10,43
Fully loaded(ad spend + agency fee) ÷ all new customers€38,81+€5,86
Paidad spend ÷ new customers from a paid click€51,72−€7,05
One store's month: €15.000 of ads, a €2.000 agency fee and 438 new customers, each CAC held against the €44,68 a first order leaves.

The three are not rival truths; they answer different questions. Blended CAC says what growth costs the business, and it is the one that cannot lie about the month, because every euro and every new customer comes from the store's own books. Paid CAC says what the ads buy at the edge, which is the sharper question when deciding whether to spend more. But it leans on attribution: a customer who clicked an ad and also searched for the brand may be counted by two platforms, the same overlap that makes the platforms' revenue claims add up to more than the store took. nouz reports blended CAC, deliberately, with no attribution model and no tracking pixel.

The ceiling: what a first order can pay

A CAC means nothing until it is held against what an order leaves. The ceiling is break-even CAC: the CM2 of a first order, its net revenue after products, shipping, packing and payment fees. On this store an average order leaves €44,68. At the blended €34,25, the first order pays for its customer and keeps €10,43; fully loaded, it keeps €5,86; at the paid €51,72 it covers 86% of the cost, and the second order has to earn back the rest.

Buying a customer at a loss on the first order is a strategy, not a mistake, as long as the repeat orders come and the cash lasts until they do. A store has to buy the stock for the second order before the second order arrives, so a long wait is money tied up exactly when growth is fastest. The CAC payback period calculator works out how many orders and months the rest takes at your own repeat rate.

What a good CAC is for an online store

There is no benchmark worth borrowing, because a good CAC is set by your own margin. Held against revenue, €34,25 is 40% of the €84,99 an average order brings in, which sounds cheap and says nothing; held against the €44,68 that order leaves, it is 77% of everything the order can pay for. A good CAC is one a first order's CM2 covers, or one the repeat orders cover soon enough for your cash.

Over a customer's whole life the same test becomes the LTV:CAC ratio: what customers were worth within a set number of days, after refunds and in CM2, against what winning them cost. And when the question is one platform rather than the whole budget, the floor a platform's reported return has to clear is the subject of what is a good ROAS.

CAC is not CPA

A platform's cost per acquisition, CPA, divides that platform's spend by the conversions it claims, repeat buyers included, and an order another platform also claims is counted again. It is a fair way to compare two campaigns inside one account. CAC counts customers, new ones only, won by all the marketing together, which is why it can be set against your books and CPA cannot. Add up the platforms' CPAs and you get a figure for customers who partly do not exist.

Which costs belong in it

  • Every ad platform's spend, from its billing page, on the day it was spent.
  • Agency retainers, creative production and influencer fees, when their job is winning customers.
  • Not a first-order discount: a welcome code is already off the price, so it lowers the first order's revenue and its CM2 instead of being counted twice.
  • Salaries of the people running marketing: a choice. Include them for the cost of the whole function, leave them out to keep CAC a variable cost, and write down which.

In nouz the marketing line of the statement holds the ad platforms' spend, CSV imports, Shopify's Shop Campaigns where Shopify reports them, and any marketing spend entered on the Overhead page under Add cost, then Marketing spend, so an agency fee entered there is inside every CAC nouz shows. Insights, Marketing divides that line by the customers whose first order falls in the dates you pick, and Insights, Customers sets the average first order's CM2 beside it, which is the ceiling test for the whole store. The MER and blended CAC calculator works out the same figure from your own month before a store is connected.

Steer on blended, check against paid

Run the business on blended CAC against the ceiling, because it is the one figure no platform can inflate. Use paid CAC as a check on the edge of the budget: when it climbs well above the ceiling while blended stays below it, the extra spend is buying customers the store would partly have won anyway. Set the month's acquisition budget from the margin rather than from last month, which is what the marketing budget planner does, and read the result where it lands, as profit after ad spend.

Questions

Questions, answered.

How do you get customer acquisition cost?
Add up the marketing spend of a period from the platforms' billing pages and anything else you paid to win customers, then divide it by the new customers whose first order falls in the same period. €15.000 over 438 new customers is €34,25.
What is a good customer acquisition cost for ecommerce?
One that a first order's CM2, what it leaves after products, shipping and payment fees, covers, or that repeat orders cover soon enough for your cash. On the month above, €34,25 against €44,68 of CM2 leaves the first order €10,43 ahead.
What is the difference between blended and paid CAC?
Blended CAC divides all marketing spend by every new customer, however they arrived. Paid CAC divides ad spend by only the new customers who came through a paid click, so it is higher, and it depends on attribution that can count one customer on two platforms.
Is CAC the same as CPA?
No. A platform's CPA divides its own spend by the conversions it claims, repeat buyers and doubly claimed orders included. CAC divides all marketing spend by new customers only, from your own books, so it is the one to set against your margins.
Should discounts count in customer acquisition cost?
Not as spend. A first-order discount is already taken off the order's revenue, so it lowers the CM2 that CAC is held against. Counting it in CAC as well would charge it twice.

Run these numbers on your own store.

Install nouz in minutes from the Shopify App Store. It imports every order your store has ever taken and builds the full P&L from your own costs, every day. Cancel anytime.

Your trialToday
14 days of nouz, every feature$0
Card needed to startNone
Access to your storeRead-only
Due today$0